I originally addressed this on Substack, but I decided it should live here, too, because I know y’all like hearing about the behind-the-scenes of Airbnb hosting.
This is going to be a niche topic, but there’s a lot of hubbub both in the Airbnb host world and the general public about Airbnb’s new stipulation that there can be no rules for guests. Rumor is, this is coming out of the extreme cleaning lists that some Airbnbs have. I’ve never personally encountered one of those, nor have I have ever thought twice about taking out my trash after a stay. So I think it’s more of a thing that people like to talk about on social media than something that happens in reality.
But, regardless, I know people are curious about it, and I’ve had a few people ask what I think. One fellow host even told me they’re thinking of switching to all paper plates since they feel like they can’t ask people to do their own dishes.

My take: this is much ado about nothing.
At our cottage and in our basement apartment, we do ask people not to leave food and dirty dishes out because we don’t want bugs. And, particularly out in the country, if you leave food and dishes out, you will get bugs. It’s never been an issue for us because most normal human beings don’t want to live amidst filth for days at a time (that’s not to say it hasn’t happened, but it’s extremely rare).
In the basement, we don’t ask them to do anything at all, but almost every guest starts the dishwasher. They’re paying significantly less than a hotel (typically, 50% of what a hotel nearby is), they’re getting more (a kitchen, a living room), and, even if they never run into us during their stay, I think they do feel personal accountability of some sort. Like a, “I want to be a respectful guest because I know the host lives upstairs.”
Also, a while back, long before all of this, I did an Instagram poll asking how people leave hotel rooms because, personally, I even make the bed. I want it to look like I wasn’t there! And, it turns out, so do most people.
That’s all to say, as a host, I am not worried about these new Airbnb rules. As a guest, I’ve never encountered wild demands. The extremes are just what does well on social media. But I’m always here to share my thoughts, so feel free to let me know whenever you have a question in this realm!
P.S. It’s funny I started writing this last week, and, since then, I received a message from a recent guest who didn’t care for our decor (you might wonder why she booked a place that didn’t agree with her tastes…and I don’t have an answer!).
I knew from her very first message to us, before she ever arrived, that she is someone who probably benefits from a level of anonymity that you can get in a large hotel, but that does not exist when you’re communicating directly with an Airbnb owner. And, throughout her stay, boy, was I right. It doesn’t take much effort to act like a normal human, and perhaps that’s what this all comes down to, whether it’s about putting a coffee mug in a dishwasher or not being rude just for the sake of being rude.